purplecat: The Tardis against the spiralling clock face effect of the Capaldi opening credits. (Doctor Who)
[personal profile] purplecat

Doctor Who annuals, necessarily constrained to telling very short stories aimed primarily at 10 year olds often written by people who have never seen the show, have a tendency towards the bland and a bit rubbish, occasionally enlivened with stuff that is a bit bonkers. The annuals in the late 1970s went for the bonkers end of the spectrum with enthusiasm which these days makes them far more interesting than many of the others. As a child I recall just being very bemused by both the story-telling and the artwork which seemed to bear relatively little relation to the show I loved.

I recall the above panel clearly. The Doctor has helped a group of apparently very nice men escape from a planet on which they were trapped, only for it to be revealed that once outside the special atmosphere of the planet they revert to psychotic monsters. This panel reveals them in their monstrous state (their psychosis is never actually shown to us, were are simply told they are also psychotic). The Doctor tricks them back down onto the planet by pretending to be stranded and, despite being (allegedly) psychotically evil, they return because of the debt they owe him. They are not happy to find themselves trapped once more and the Doctor (in a detail I missed as a child) weeps as he abandons them.

It's a difficult story. Even as a child I was concerned that the Doctor accepted so easily that these creatures must be evil and I do wonder if its trying to say something about assumptions that to be ugly is the same as to be evil (a message Doctor Who occasionally strays into, much as it also has stories that assert the opposite). Given the Doctor's tears at the end I wonder if the artist also had doubts about the message the story seemed to be conveying.

All that said, it has the merit of not being remotely bland.

(no subject)

Date: 2017-04-29 12:57 pm (UTC)
sir_guinglain: (Tom)
From: [personal profile] sir_guinglain
A neighbour has a Heron Books set of the James Herriot series illustrated by Paul Crompton who I think painted that picture above. The style is definitely his, but alarming (in its own way) for him not to be subjecting the world of All Creatures... to this kind of psychodramatic treatment.

(no subject)

Date: 2017-04-30 09:45 am (UTC)
major_clanger: Clangers (Royal Mail stamp) (Default)
From: [personal profile] major_clanger
I have a dim memory of this. Even as a youngster, it would sometimes strike me that the stories in Doctor Who annuals were showing the Doctor acting in a very, well un-Doctor-like fashion.

The DWM comics seemed to suffer from this less. Were the comic writers given more guidance or subject to more oversight than the annual writers perhaps?


purplecat: Hand Drawn picture of a Toy Cat (Default)

September 2017

     1 2
3 4 5678 9
10 11 12 131415 16
171819 20212223


Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags